Ministers are facing increasing pressure from council leaders and teaching unions to reconsider their plans to open primary schools in England to more pupils from next month.
Calderdale Council in West Yorkshire has joined a number of local authorities in advising its schools against reopening more widely to Reception, Year 1 and Year 6 pupils from 1 June amid safety concerns.
Solihull Council, believed to be one of the first Conservative-led local authorities to question the government’s proposed start date, has warned that some school places may not be ready for the first week of June.
It came as a poll from teachers’ union NASUWT suggested that only 5% of teachers think it will be safe for more pupils to return to school next month.
In a letter to the education secretary, NASUWT general secretary Patrick Roach said the union remains “unconvinced” that wider reopening of schools from 1 June is “appropriate or practicable”.
The survey, of nearly 29,000 NASUWT members across England, found that around nine in 10 teachers believe that social distancing will be impossible, or will present major issues and a similar proportion are not confident that the proposed measures will protect their health or the health of pupils.
We’re advising Calderdale schools not to open more widely until they can be confident that children and teaching staff are able to return to classrooms safely.
The Government has set five key tests guiding any decision to re-open. Find out more👉https://t.co/EOUiSE6EtW#Covid19 pic.twitter.com/EcXaVFNju1
— Calderdale Council #StayHomeSaveLives (@Calderdale) May 19, 2020
It also found that 87% of teachers believe that PPE is essential to protect staff against the virus.
Dr Roach said: “The results of our survey underscore the fact that the government has thus far failed to win the trust and confidence of teachers about the safety of reopening schools.
“It is now imperative that the government takes every available opportunity to provide the necessary assurances that teachers are seeking.”
The union leader called for all the scientific evidence from the government’s Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies (SAGE) to be made available to teachers and school as soon as possible.
It came as education unions told the PA news agency that they were due to meet education secretary Gavin Williamson on Tuesday as part of a weekly conference on the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic on schools.
Calderdale Council became the latest Labour-led council in the north of England to advise its schools against a wider reopening from 1 June, following similar actions from Bury, Liverpool and Hartlepool.
A number of local authorities in England have acknowledged safety concerns among parents and teachers over the date, but they have not urged all their schools to reject the proposed time frame.
In a major survey of #NASUWT members 29k responded and the results were that: 85% of teachers do not think it will be safe to return on 1 June
— NASUWT (@NASUWT) May 19, 2020
John Edmunds, professor of infectious disease modelling at London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, said the decision to reopen primary schools is a political decision but he said it may be that children are less likely to transmit coronavirus to others.
He told the House of Lords science and technology committee: “Clearly the decision to open primary schools or not is a political one; it’s not a scientific decision. Scientists can offer some advice.
“It looks like the risk to children is low, and that the vast majority don’t have significant symptoms.”
He added: “So the risk to others may be relatively low, but overall you have to weigh up those risks with other things, risks to community, clearly we can’t keep children off school forever, and so on and so forth.
“The actual decision, and weighing all of those things, needs to be done by politicians.”
