Reappointing Welsh Labour Leader Carwyn Jones as Wales’ First Minister was meant to be a formality. But when Plaid Cymru put up Leanne Wood as an alternative leader on Wednesday, Ukip and the Conservatives unexpectedly voted for her. With the vote tied, the Welsh Assembly finds itself in limbo – and dramatic accusations are flying. So what’s really going on?
On Wednesday, the Welsh Assembly convened to vote on who would become Wales’ First Minister. Although Welsh Labour lost its overall majority in the Welsh Assembly when it lost one seat on May 5, it was widely assumed that Labour would form a minority government, with 29 of the 60 seats in the Senedd.
But Plaid Cymru, which won 12 seats in the elections, pushing the Conservatives into third place with 11, put Leanne Wood up as an alternative First Minister. And the Conservatives and Ukip’s seven new Assembly Members all voted for her. With Wood winning 29 votes, it was down to the sole Lib Dem Assembly Member, Kirsty Williams, to give Carwyn Jones her vote and save Labour from defeat (the two Presiding Officers – one Plaid and one Labour – did not vote).
The result has led to dramatic fallout on social media, with accusations and counter-accusations of hypocrisy, arrogance and backroom deal-making flying between Plaid and Welsh Labour politicians and their supporters.
At the heart of the intrigue is the question of whether Plaid Cymru did a deal with Ukip over the vote. During the election campaign, Plaid promised that voting for Plaid would stop Ukip – and Leanne Wood won many fans by putting Nigel Farage in his place in a general election leaders debate in 2015.
Neil Hamilton, the disgraced former Conservative MP who has just won a seat in Wales as a Ukip candidate, claims he was approached by Plaid and asked to back Leanne Wood in the vote:
.@NeilUKIP says that UKIP was approached by Plaid on Monday to back Leanne Wood in the FM vote
— BBC Wales Politics (@WalesPolitics) May 11, 2016
— Arwyn Jones (@jonesarwyn) May 11, 2016
The Welsh Conservatives have also hinted there were discussions ahead of the vote, with Leader Andrew RT Davies saying:
I sense an appetite for a new kind of Welsh collaborative government, and would welcome further discussions to build on those which led to today’s debate.
Plaid, on the other hand, categorically deny any deal was done, saying:
The Plaid Cymru group followed normal Parliamentary protocol and nominated Leanne Wood for First Minister. Carwyn Jones was informed of this decision yesterday. Since that time, and as far as Plaid Cymru is aware, there have been no formal discussions, agreements or deals pursued between any party.
In fact, the party says it was surprised that Ukip and the Conservatives voted for Leanne Wood:
Plaid say they did not want to give Labour a bloody nose and surprised other parties supported them.
— Nick Servini (@NickServini) May 11, 2016
Plaid Assembly Member Simon Thomas said his party had put Leanne Wood up as leader to “check” Labour’s “arrogance”:
The first thing we want to achieve is that Labour is checked and reminded that it doesn’t have a majority and has to work with other parties. The second thing we want is proper discussions. … It’s about Labour recognising that they will need the support of other parties almost on a daily basis. They can’t simply expect to put together the sort of programme and arrogant and lazy government that we’ve had for the last five years.
But Welsh Labour accused Plaid of hypocrisy and betrayal:
So much for progressive politics. Plaid spent 8 weeks telling voters they WOULDN'T do a deal with UKIP or the Tories pic.twitter.com/yWMcTCr6eW
— Welsh Labour Press (@WelshLabPress) May 11, 2016
Any claim @LeanneWood had to be a socialist or Plaid to be a progressive party has just been destroyed by her alliance with Tories and UKIP.
— Owen Smith (@OwenSmith_MP) May 11, 2016
If I were @LeanneWood I'd only be interested in forming a progressive government. If i'd to rely on Tories/UKIP to win, I'd say no thanks
— Chris Bryant (@RhonddaBryant) May 11, 2016
Still following? Good, because this is where it starts to get complicated.
Welsh Ukip appears to be a divided party after Neil Hamilton ousted Welsh Ukip’s existing leader Nathan Gill on Tuesday (it’s been a busy week in Wales). And on Thursday, BBC Wales reported that two Assembly Members for Ukip – including Nathan Gill – could split from the rest of their party and vote for Carwyn Jones over Leanne Wood:
UKIP AMs Nathan Gill and Mark Reckless are preparing to back Carwyn Jones’s bid to be re-elected first minister, BBC Wales understands.
This generated suggestions that Welsh Labour had done a deal with Ukip, forcing Labour to announce that:
There are no formal talks with any parties currently and certainly not Ukip.
And Ukip’s Nathan Gill gave the same story.
At the time of writing, Carwyn Jones remains First Minister while the Senedd remains in an unprecedented stalemate – and it will stay that way until an agreement is reached or a new election called.
It is unclear how this sorry state of affairs came to happen. What we do know is that relations between Welsh Labour and Plaid Cymru – who have worked together in a coalition government in the past – seem to have soured after a Welsh Labour Assembly Member called Plaid a “cheap date” a couple of months ago. Sources in Labour say they recently offered Plaid involvement in setting the Welsh budget and designing policy – but Plaid says that never happened:
— Arwyn Jones (@jonesarwyn) May 11, 2016
Plaid, on the other hand, says Leanne Wood asked for a week-long delay in the vote for First Minister to allow further negotiations to take place, but she was turned down. In fact, it seems that any kind of formal talks between Wales’ two biggest parties have yet to happen.
And we also know that, while Welsh Labour has received a seriously bloody nose and Plaid Cymru has had its reputation damaged by association with Ukip, there are two parties that have come out of the whole affair laughing (most probably literally): Ukip and the Conservatives.
In fact, Richard Wyn Jones, Professor of Welsh Politics at Cardiff, suggests that the whole fiasco could be a bit of Ukip/Conservative mischief-making:
Plaid attempt to form minority govt with 12 AMs not serious. Combined with Tory/ukip devilment has left plaid having to manage climbdown 1/2
— Richard Wyn Jones (@RWynJones) May 11, 2016
Being asked about 'devilment' comment. Tories and UKIP voted for an FM who wants Wales to be an independent country within EU! = Devilment!
— Richard Wyn Jones (@RWynJones) May 11, 2016
So it may yet turn out that the only deal that has been done is between Welsh Ukip and its new leader’s former colleagues in the Conservative party. And, if that is the case, it’s probably time that Wales’ two biggest parties – Plaid and Labour – stopped bashing each other on social media and started talking.
We need your help to keep speaking the truth
Every story that you have come to us with; each injustice you have asked us to investigate; every campaign we have fought; each of your unheard voices we amplified; we do this for you. We are making a difference on your behalf.
Our fight is your fight. You’ve supported our collective struggle every time you gave us a like; and every time you shared our work across social media. Now we need you to support us with a monthly donation.
We have published nearly 2,000 articles and over 50 films in 2021. And we want to do this and more in 2022 but we don’t have enough money to go on at this pace. So, if you value our work and want us to continue then please join us and be part of The Canary family.
In return, you get:
* Advert free reading experience
* Quarterly group video call with the Editor-in-Chief
* Behind the scenes monthly e-newsletter
* 20% discount in our shop
Almost all of our spending goes to the people who make The Canary’s content. So your contribution directly supports our writers and enables us to continue to do what we do: speaking truth, powered by you. We have weathered many attempts to shut us down and silence our vital opposition to an increasingly fascist government and right-wing mainstream media.
With your help we can continue:
* Holding political and state power to account
* Advocating for the people the system marginalises
* Being a media outlet that upholds the highest standards
* Campaigning on the issues others won’t
* Putting your lives central to everything we do
We are a drop of truth in an ocean of deceit. But we can’t do this without your support. So please, can you help us continue the fight?