On 27 June, John Humphrys interviewed Tony Blair on BBC Radio 4‘s Today programme. The BBC claimed that Humphrys had ‘challenged’ Blair’s own immigration record. But during the interview, Humphrys actually shared some alarmingly right-wing rhetoric about immigrants and immigration.
‘Millions upon millions’
Blair is due to give a speech warning that a:
return to the dark era that saw the rise of the Nazis is “no longer far-fetched”.
But as Humphrys interviewed Blair, the BBC presenter’s choice of words in discussing refugees and immigrants had its own chilling echoes of this ‘dark era’.
Both Blair and Humphrys mentioned the Schengen Area and the upcoming summit between EU leaders to fix the ‘migration crisis’. But throughout the segment, there was no acknowledgement of the current refugee crisis – a partial result of the actions of Britain and its international allies. Instead, both referred to ‘immigrants’, not ‘refugees’, throughout. And it’s this wording and lack of context that is all too common in right-wing rhetoric today.
It doesn’t make them racist. It doesn’t make them anti-foreigners. But ‘you’ people… ‘us’, if you like: well-heeled, well-educated, nice liberal views, not threatened by immigrants in the sense that you worry about getting that appointment at your doctor’s surgery or where your child’s going to go to school, or whether the immigrant’s going to take your job and all that.
But he continued to use rhetoric that many would feel unnecessarily dehumanising. He went on to ask Blair:
What do you do now about all of these people who want to come here? And there are millions, upon millions, upon millions of them… They’re out there. They’re either on their way here, or planning to come here. And millions have already come here.
Some people took to Twitter to share their thoughts about Humphrys openly sharing this kind of rhetoric. Because it seems utterly at odds with the BBC‘s claim to be impartial.
Many pointed out that this wouldn’t be unexpected from the Mail, or other right-wing outlets:
In today’s episode of John Humphrys’s Daily Mail Monologues (formerly known as @BBCr4today) “millions and millions and millions and millions of migrants”. I’d love the BBC to explain to me how this sort of toxic editorialising is balanced and in tune with their charter. #r4today pic.twitter.com/uoYiJmbsUh
— Alex Andreou (@sturdyAlex) June 27, 2018
If you can't find a copy of the Daily Mail then just tune into John Humphrys on #r4today where you will find the same level of ignorant gossip
— Andy Birss (@1957AJB) June 27, 2018
Some, meanwhile, complained to the BBC:
I no longer listen but heard a clip on sm. just horrified by the whole "interview" and the terrible language of John Humphrys. @BBCRadio4 @BBCNews @BBCr4today please add my complaint to the many I'm sure you have received and please act on our concerns https://t.co/xECJoAWjS5
— sylvia rothschild #FBPE (@rabbisylvia) June 27, 2018
Because broadcasting these views as if they were “facts” is a problem:
People believe that migrants cause housing shortages and waiting times in the health service because Paul Dacre, John Humphrys and rightwing politicians tell them so. This is not about being out of touch, this is about irresponsible lies. https://t.co/QNuUtzQ80f
— Carsten Timmermann (@ctimmermann) June 27, 2018
Others pointed out quite how ludicrous the whole segment actually was:
If you want a presenter who rants uncontrollably about immigrants over the top of his interviewees, why not replace John Humphrys with Nigel Farage? You'd save a lot of money.#r4today
— Why to vote Green #FBPE (@WhyToVoteGreen) June 27, 2018
Humphrys almost made Blair look reasonable. That’s the same Blair who took the UK into the invasion of Iraq – fuelling a war that killed hundreds of thousands of people; that the high court ruled was “unnecessary”; and that both the US and the UK knew could lead to a rise in terrorism (as it did). This is the same man that many think should be prosecuted as a war criminal.
So when a BBC journalist makes Blair almost seem reasonable by repeating far-right propaganda, we know that the mainstream media really shouldn’t be trusted.
– Join The Canary, so we can keep holding the powerful to account.
Featured image via screengrab
We need your help ...
The coronavirus pandemic is changing our world, fast. And we will do all we can to keep bringing you news and analysis throughout. But we are worried about maintaining enough income to pay our staff and minimal overheads.
Now, more than ever, we need a vibrant, independent media that holds the government to account and calls it out when it puts vested economic interests above human lives. We need a media that shows solidarity with the people most affected by the crisis – and one that can help to build a world based on collaboration and compassion.
We have been fighting against an establishment that is trying to shut us down. And like most independent media, we don’t have the deep pockets of investors to call on to bail us out.
Can you help by chipping in a few pounds each month?