• Disrupting Power Since 2015
  • Donate
  • Login
Wednesday, May 14, 2025
  • Login
  • Register
Canary
MEDIA THAT DISRUPTS
  • News
    • UK
    • Global
    • Analysis
    • Trending
  • Editorial
  • Features
    • Features
    • Environment
    • Lifestyle
    • Health
    • Money
    • Science
    • Business
    • Tech
    • Travel
    • Sport & Gaming
  • Media
    • Video
    • Cartoons
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
MANAGE SUBSCRIPTION
SUPPORT
  • News
    • UK
    • Global
    • Analysis
    • Trending
  • Editorial
  • Features
    • Features
    • Environment
    • Lifestyle
    • Health
    • Money
    • Science
    • Business
    • Tech
    • Travel
    • Sport & Gaming
  • Media
    • Video
    • Cartoons
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
Canary
No Result
View All Result

The SNP’s Angus Robertson smoothly obliterates Cameron at PMQs, with one killer question (VIDEO)

James Wright by James Wright
13 April 2016
in UK
Reading Time: 4 mins read
160 12
A A
0
Home UK
320
SHARES
2.5k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

At Prime Minister’s Questions (PMQs) on Wednesday, Angus Robertson’s first question unravelled all of David Cameron’s rhetoric on tackling tax dodging. Cameron had spent the entire first half of PMQs championing his record:

The difference I think between this side of the house and the honourable gentleman is we believe in setting low tax rates and encouraging people to pay them. And it’s working.

Then Cameron’s weekly joust with Jeremy Corbyn was over and Cameron thought he was home dry. Until the SNP Westminster leader asked:

3,250 Department of Work and Pensions (DWP) staff have been specifically investigating benefit fraud, while only 300 HMRC staff have been systematically investigating tax evasion. Surely we should care equally about people abusing the tax system and those abusing the benefit system. Why has this government had 10 times more staff dealing with often the poorest in society abusing benefits, than with the super rich evading their taxes?

HMRC has only 300 people working in its Affluent Compliance Unit. This division specifically investigates millionaires and those earning over £150,000 for tax evasion. Meanwhile, the DWP has 3,250 people investigating specifically ordinary low paid people for benefit fraud. Cameron responded with the well-rehearsed government response to this point:

I would look carefully at his statistics, but they sound to entirely bogus. For this reason: the predominant job of the DWP is to make sure that people receive their benefits. The predominant job of HMRC is to make sure people pay their taxes. The 26,000 people I spoke about earlier, all of them are making sure people pay their taxes.

Well yes, there are 26,000 people working at the ‘enforcement and compliance’ HMRC department – 4,000 less under recent cuts from Cameron. But this figure includes all the employees undertaking huge admin work as well as tackling tax fraud. This department is around 36% of the whole of HMRC, which in 2009 said it had 74,430 full-time employees.

After PMQs on Wednesday, Adam Bienkov produced a “PMQs factcheck” at politics.co.uk which took the existence of this department as proof Robertson’s claim was bogus:

Either way, it seems pretty clear that Roberton’s statistic, as eye-catching and meme-worthy as it may be, is about as reliable as most other figures that tend to go viral on Twitter.

However, the very reason the government has a special division for tackling rich tax evaders is because that is not the focus of the wider HMRC department. And similar applies to the DWP. The DWP is responsible for the entire welfare state which is why it dedicates a special division to focus on benefit fraud.

So we have one special division for the super rich fraudsters and one for the poor benefit cheats. Yet the team tackling the latter has ten times the manpower of the former.

Now, if the government’s objective is to retrieve as much money as possible, then it should focus on catching the fraudsters that take the most money away. Thus, we would expect the benefit cheats to take at least ten times more from the public purse than the super rich. As one would expect, this could not be further from the truth.

Renowned economist Richard Murphy estimates that Britain now loses more than £82.1 billion per year from tax evasion alone. That does not include the legal tax dodging – tax avoidance – carried about by the likes of the Prime Minister, which stood at £19.1bn for 2013/14.  In the UK, the top five richest families have more money than the bottom 20% of the country. It is only the super rich that have billions to hide. Therefore, this estimated £82 billion loss will be almost entirely due to wealthy high earners. The very people those 300 people at the Affluent Compliance Unit are tasked to investigate.

Meanwhile, it is estimated that benefit fraud loses us £1.2bn per year. This is a whopping a 68 times less than the tax evasion carried out by the super rich. Yet the government employs ten times more people to specifically tackle it.

This is dodgy. Considering the affluent are responsible for the majority of the tax gap, the majority of the HMRC’s ‘enforcement and compliance’ department should be targeting them. Instead, there are just 300 on the case, compared to the 3,250 people targeting the poorest.

‘One rule for us, another for them’ has never been more applicable. At PMQs on Wednesday, Robertson’s killer question left Cameron visibly flustered. The tax collecting record he had just spent the entire debate championing unravelled before his eyes:

https://youtu.be/-9bedRhmrf4?t=15m25s

Get Involved!

– Join the People’s Assembly “March For Health, Homes, Jobs And Education” on Saturday 16 April.

Featured image via Youtube screenshot.

Share128Tweet80
Previous Post

Becoming unemployed alters the way you think, and it’s not all bad

Next Post

Corbyn’s comeback at PMQs over tax puts Cameron in his place (VIDEO)

Next Post
Corbyn’s comeback at PMQs over tax puts Cameron in his place (VIDEO)

Corbyn's comeback at PMQs over tax puts Cameron in his place (VIDEO)

The Telegraph’s attack on ‘£3 million Corbyn’ is an act of desperation (VIDEO)

The Telegraph’s attack on '£3 million Corbyn' is an act of desperation (VIDEO)

Cameron thinks this £9 million leaflet would present his party as unified, it does the opposite

Cameron thinks this £9 million leaflet would present his party as unified, it does the opposite

Brexit supporters get creative with David Cameron’s £9m pro-EU leaflets (TWEETS, IMAGES)

Brexit supporters get creative with David Cameron’s £9m pro-EU leaflets (TWEETS, IMAGES)

STIs: Bringing you itching, burning… and a long happy marriage?

STIs: Bringing you itching, burning... and a long happy marriage?

The Independent Alliance just brilliantly exposed the corporate media's pro-genocide bias
Trending

The Independent Alliance just brilliantly exposed the corporate media’s pro-genocide bias

by Ed Sykes
13 May 2025
Tesla Takedown rallies planned at company's UK advertising events
News

Campaigners are set to celebrate Tesla’s nosediving car sales – by hijacking its own events

by The Canary
13 May 2025
Tony Blair climate denial
News

Activists have just dragged Tony Blair over his rampant climate denialism

by The Canary
13 May 2025
A petition calling for the end to the badger cull just passed 100,000 signatures so will be heading for parliamentary debate
News

The badger cull is set for a parliamentary debate – all thanks to a viral petition

by The Canary
13 May 2025
Israel kills journalist Hassan Eslaih in Gaza hospital strike
Analysis

Israel kills journalist in Gaza hospital bombing, and its media debates whether that’s OK

by Ed Sykes
13 May 2025
  • Contact
  • About & FAQ
  • Get our Daily News Email
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy

The Canary
PO Box 71199
LONDON
SE20 9EX

Canary Media Ltd – registered in England. Company registration number 09788095.

For guest posting, contact [email protected]

For other enquiries, contact: [email protected]

The Canary is owned and run by independent journalists and volunteers, NOT offshore billionaires.

You can write for us, or support us by making a regular or one-off donation.

© Canary Media Ltd 2024, all rights reserved | Website by Monster | Hosted by Krystal | Privacy Settings

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • UK
    • Global
    • Analysis
    • Trending
  • Editorial
  • Features
    • Features
    • Environment
    • Lifestyle
    • Health
    • Money
    • Science
    • Business
    • Tech
    • Travel
    • Sport & Gaming
  • Media
    • Video
    • Cartoons
  • Opinion

© 2023 Canary - Worker's co-op.

Before you go, have you seen...?

The Independent Alliance just brilliantly exposed the corporate media's pro-genocide bias
Trending
Ed Sykes

The Independent Alliance just brilliantly exposed the corporate media’s pro-genocide bias

Tesla Takedown rallies planned at company's UK advertising events
News
The Canary

Campaigners are set to celebrate Tesla’s nosediving car sales – by hijacking its own events

Tony Blair climate denial
News
The Canary

Activists have just dragged Tony Blair over his rampant climate denialism

A petition calling for the end to the badger cull just passed 100,000 signatures so will be heading for parliamentary debate
News
The Canary

The badger cull is set for a parliamentary debate – all thanks to a viral petition

ADVERTISEMENT
Tech
Nathan Spears

How Digital Addictions Are Formed in the Shadow of Large Platforms

Lifestyle
Nathan Spears

Recovery in the Sun: How the Canary Islands are Becoming a Wellness Tourism Hub

Lifestyle
Nathan Spears

Why More People Are Seeking Legal Advice When Separating