We all need to listen to the woman on Question Time last night. Our future depends on it.

BBC Question Time audience members on 9 January 2020
Ed Sykes

A Question Time audience member broke through the babble with a vital message on 9 January. And it’s one that British people need to deal with urgently if they’re going to win the class war which economic and political elites are waging against them.

Take on the media establishment, or face defeat again and again

The woman first called out the “relentless campaign” of misinformation and attacks against Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn by the UK’s billionaire press. She then insisted that “anyone standing for socialism will receive the same thing” and that establishment media outlets “will not let a socialist be elected in this country”:

Billionaires dominate Britain’s media environment today. Just three companies control around 83% of newspapers – an increase from 71% back in 2015. Roughly 80% of online media, meanwhile, sits with only five companies. In short, press barons and their establishment allies have immense power to wage class war against ordinary people through the media. As part of this, they’ve played a key role in vilifying Corbyn via a years-long war of smears:

With this in mind, the British people desperately need a media revolution. Because without one, the country’s elites will keep clutching onto power with all their might.

Shame on the media

Britain’s billionaire media wasn’t about to let Labour’s massive breakthrough in the 2017 election happen again. So it went all out in the 2019 election to stop Corbyn’s party from winning. As three academics wrote after the election, “the mainstream media continue to play a vital role in informing and priming public opinion during elections”, both offline and online. And they shared the following revealing images:

Loughborough University
Loughborough University

 

The Loughborough University research found that “press hostility to Labour was more than double the levels identified during the 2017 election” and that “negative coverage of the Conservatives almost halved in the final week of the 2019 campaign”.

But while Corbyn’s progressive policies may have been the big reason the rich and powerful hated him, they weren’t responsible in any meaningful way for voters backing Boris Johnson and the Tories. Because Brexit, overwhelmingly, was the key factor for the electorate (along with related issues and media smears). And as Prof Natalie Fenton wrote after the election, the Tories kept Brexit at the forefront. Their “rebuttal tactics were robust”, she said, with them simply ‘side-stepping’ issues where they were weak and repeating “Get Brexit Done” (which itself was misleading). Johnson himself, meanwhile, consistently hid from media scrutiny as his party “focused on messages that would be crowd-pleasing, circulate rapidly and feed off emotional responses rather than accuracy”. As media lecturer Justin Schlosberg said:

Historian Mark Curtis also slammed media complicity:

Politics is not a level playing field

Prof Des Freedman recently wrote that:

Class war dominated this election.

He explained how the Tories launched “an offensive to defend elite power and privilege” which “involved both vilifying and ridiculing Labour policies”. And he stressed that:

The Tories flooded Facebook (especially in the last week of the campaign) with ads, 88% of which, according to First Draft, contained misleading claims

This wasn’t helped by the fact that Facebook gives political posts a free pass on fact-checking.

TV broadcasters, meanwhile, allowed easy issues for Johnson to dominate coverage. And:

unencumbered by a responsibility to tell the truth, Johnson simply lied on air … knowing that by the time the fact checkers got around to challenging their veracity, the damage was already done.

The BBC‘s behaviour in particular consistently favoured the Tories.

As Freedman insisted:

Many weapons are used in class war but media power is a central part of the generals’ arsenal.

For that reason, he said, “any radical opposition… will need an insurgent movement to face this down”. That means all progressives need to turn away from establishment media and give their full support to independent media. Because without that, the Question Time audience member’s predictions will come true. 

Featured image via screenshot

We need your help ...

The coronavirus pandemic is changing our world, fast. And we will do all we can to keep bringing you news and analysis throughout. But we are worried about maintaining enough income to pay our staff and minimal overheads.

Now, more than ever, we need a vibrant, independent media that holds the government to account and calls it out when it puts vested economic interests above human lives. We need a media that shows solidarity with the people most affected by the crisis – and one that can help to build a world based on collaboration and compassion.

We have been fighting against an establishment that is trying to shut us down. And like most independent media, we don’t have the deep pockets of investors to call on to bail us out.

Can you help by chipping in a few pounds each month?

The Canary Support us
  • Show Comments
    1. I’ve noticed a shift with anyone who really knows anything have been turning to alternative media to speak their mind. The Cabal of the journalistic crime scene has begun to be ignored by any civil minded person. Forget about politics, we are talking about civil society’s survival.

    Leave a Reply

    Join the conversation

    Please read our comment moderation policy here.