The corporate media and its pundits were quick to try and blame Jeremy Corbyn for Boris Johnson’s nightmarish election win on 12 December. But there are two massive factors to blame that they won’t be analysing in-depth any time soon. These are:
- The mainstream media’s endless, years-long propaganda about Corbyn and its utter failure to hold Johnson’s Conservatives to account. This has been a powerful weapon in the UK’s class war, protecting and campaigning for the interests of the rich and powerful. And it highlights the desperate, ongoing need for a radical democratisation of Britain’s media.
- Our electoral system giving the Tories a majority of MPs even though it got a minority of votes. The devastating division of the anti-Tory vote, meanwhile, helped to hand the Conservatives seats that united anti-Tory candidates could have won easily. This horror story highlights the urgent need for electoral reform.
Without a media revolution, the ultra-rich will continue to dominate
Brexit was undoubtedly a key factor in the election, handing the Brexit-obsessed Tories numerous longstanding Labour seats because many people perceived Labour’s position on Brexit as an attempt to undo the 2016 referendum result. But other issues were clearly important too. So in stepped the billionaires who dominate Britain’s mainstream media. And their information war against Corbyn’s Labour (both on Brexit and other issues) surely helped to tip the scales in Johnson’s favour. As comedian Frankie Boyle wrote:
Labour has been monstered in the media throughout the campaign, and largely been judged by different standards than the Conservatives.
Johnson, however, avoided scrutiny as much as possible. And the Tory campaign clearly focused on dirty tactics:
88% of Tory ads contained lies.
They lied re Brexit, 50k nurses, 40 hospitals.
They faked a video and fact check site
They faked news about a 4-year old & Labour spending
They paid for bots to spread fake news.
They suppressed the Russia report.
Read on...Support us and go ad-free
— David Schneider (@davidschneider) December 13, 2019
Britain’s establishment media also had a clear anti-Labour position from the very start. Even public broadcaster the BBC faced fierce criticism for its alleged pro-Tory bias. In particular, the smearing of Labour’s veteran anti-racist leader was endless (despite his party’s very strong record on stamping out racism), although there was barely a mention of the Tories’ appalling record on racism. Corbyn’s enemies in the Labour Party, meanwhile, had been fuelling this vile propaganda campaign against Corbyn ever since he became party leader. As film legend Ken Loach said:
Ken Loach blames Labour’s defeat on the media and Labour backbenchers:
“No other Labour leader has had the abuse that Jeremy Corbyn has. No other leader has been called a terrorist when he’s a man of peace, or a racist when he’s been opposed to racism all his life”. @itvnews
— Paul Brand (@PaulBrandITV) December 13, 2019
In fact, as historian Mark Curtis pointed out:
Strong performance by Corbyn to get 32% of vote in face of total demonisation from whole of media, much of his own party and the state for 4 yrs while defying (wrongly) Brexit vote. Shows popularity of non-Brexit policies and defiance of propaganda by substantial % of electorate pic.twitter.com/s1DJ3kzT0t
— Mark Curtis (@markcurtis30) December 13, 2019
Our current media is simply not fit for purpose. And if we want a truly transformative left-wing government any time soon, a media revolution is vital.
I don't want to hear a fucking word from smug sensibles saying this defeat lies at Corbyn's feet. This defeat lies firmly with the media and the politics of lies, hate, and division that has fucked our country.
— Holly (@holski_beat) December 12, 2019
Watching BBC news this morning and a Labour MP mentioned that Boris Johnson is a racist, misogynist and an islamophobe and her response is "well he's not anti-semitic is he?" 🙂????????????
— tobi childs (@Tobesss_x) December 13, 2019
Our electoral system is rotten. Continuing as we are is not an option.
Only two thirds of eligible people in the UK voted in the election, and we obviously need to reflect on why a third chose not to vote. But putting that issue to one side, our electoral system is in desperate need of a radical overhaul. Because in our current system, some votes simply matter more than others. And having to vote for a party that’s not our first choice just because it has the greatest chance of winning is all too often a necessity (particularly for progressives).
There's going to be loads of analysis of #GE2019 coming out in the next few days. Here's the most important thing to know…
Once again, the UK has a Parliament that no where near reflects how the people voted.
— Make Votes Matter (@MakeVotesMatter) December 13, 2019
Across Britain, it took…
🗳️864,743 votes to elect 1 Green MP
🗳️642,303 votes to elect 0 Brexit Party MPs
🗳️334,122 votes to elect a Lib Dem
🗳️50,817 votes for a Labour MP
🗳️38,316 votes for a Plaid Cymru MP
🗳️38,300 votes for a Con. MP
🗳️25,882 votes for a SNP MP#ScrapFPTP
— Electoral Reform Society (@electoralreform) December 13, 2019
As Green Party co-leader Sian Berry insisted:
"This election should be a wake-up call to the Labour Party. they do need to work with other parties to overcome problems with the electoral system" – @sianberry
— Make Votes Matter (@MakeVotesMatter) December 13, 2019
But smaller anti-Tory parties, fully aware of the rotten core of UK’s electoral system, also need to reflect carefully. Because in numerous places, they helped to put the Tories in power:
Green vote bigger than the difference between Labour and the Tories.
Laura Pidcock was a working class politician who backed a green new deal and ending austerity.
You have to work for every vote but this is just sickening. https://t.co/qvEumzer4H
— Aaron Bastani (@AaronBastani) December 13, 2019
This captures the appalling, reprehensible strategy of the Lib Dems perfectly. This was a Labour seat; it's now a Tory seat. Tory-enabling LibDemmery at its very worst. Sickening.#GE2019 #LibDems https://t.co/6TuOjtGJAo
— Ed Sykes (@OsoSabioUK) December 13, 2019
In other cases, a majority of people were clearly against the Tories; but pointless division in the anti-Tory vote helped to deliver a Tory MP:
— BBC Election (@bbcelection) December 13, 2019
All progressives must campaign for media and electoral reform
Parliament isn’t everything, and politics doesn’t just happen when there’s an election. We can all use our dignified rage at this nightmare election to organise creatively to improve our communities and lay the groundwork for change:
If we cannot transform society at the ballot box one year, we don't wait idly by to transform it five years on.
We create alternative strategies in the cracks and spaces that exist to demonstrate not only that another way is possible, but that another way is *better*.
— Arjan 🌹 (@arjan____) December 13, 2019
We need a grassroots Labour movement in our constituencies to engage in and start community projects to care for these people as racism, bigotry, and yet more poverty abounds. We cannot just be an engine for political campaigning, we have to be a community resource.
— Holly (@holski_beat) December 13, 2019
On a national scale, however, it’s absolutely vital in the coming months and years that both media and electoral reform are at the top of any progressive, anti-Tory agenda. Because changing both is the best way to fight back, and failing to do so could cement the Tories’ power even further.
Featured image via Tom Saint
Do your bit for independent journalism
Did you know that less than 1.5% of our readers contribute financially to The Canary? Imagine what we could do if just a few more people joined our movement to achieve a shared vision of a free and fair society where we nurture people and planet.
We need you to help out, if you can.
When you give a monthly amount to fund our work, you are supporting truly independent journalism. We hold power to account and have weathered many attempts to shut us down and silence the counterpoint to the mainstream.
You can count on us for rigorous journalism and fearless opposition to an increasingly fascist government and right wing mainstream media.
In return you get:
- Advert free reading experience
- Behind the scenes monthly e-newsletter
- 20% discount from our shop