People’s reactions to the resignation of a key councillor in the Sheffield trees saga are interesting

A tweet about the resignation of a Sheffield Labour councillor
Steve Topple

A Labour councillor at the heart of the ongoing Sheffield trees saga has resigned from his position on the city council’s cabinet. And people on social media haven’t exactly been sympathetic…

The quietening of chainsaws?

Labour-led Sheffield City Council and its contractor Amey are chopping down public trees in the city. Local residents aren’t happy because of the environmental impact, the “Thatcherite” behaviour of the Labour council, and public health concerns.

The council paused the tree-felling programme on 26 March. As the Guardian reported, it said it was doing this because of:

the actions of a handful of people unlawfully entering the safety zones where tree replacement work is being carried out.

Amid the quietening of the chainsaws, the drama has continued. In the recent local elections, Labour lost two seats to the Green Party and two to the Lib Dems.

But now, Labour councillor Bryan Lodge has quit as cabinet member for environment and Streetscene (the department responsible for the tree felling programme).

One for the chop

As the Yorkshire Post reported, Lodge quit his role on Tuesday 8 May. In a statement on Facebook, he said:

Just wanted to say, it’s been an interesting/challenging two years. To the Sheffield City Council officers – you have been awesome. Never let the truth get lost in the aggressive, nasty and personal abuse directed at us.

I’m proud to have worked with such a dedicated, hardworking and professional team of people… We need to get the people of Sheffield, all the people, back on board to realise the benefits of this biggest ever investment in the infrastructure of the city…

I hope that in years to come, others can hold their heads high because I know I can. To the campaigners, I respect your passion but can’t condone the behaviour. Respect plays both ways.


Some people on social media were not exactly shedding a tear at the news of Lodge’s departure:

Others pointed to a broader problem:

And puns inevitably followed:

Sheffield: the eye of a political storm

As The Canary has been documenting, Sheffield has become the eye of a political storm. The council is undertaking a 25-year, £2bn highway maintenance programme which includes the care and felling of trees. There have been ongoing protests from campaigners, opposition councillors, and residents over the programme.

These demonstrations have been highly charged: one saw two pensioners arrested, and another saw local residents reportedly face off against over 30 police officers, private security, and heavy plant machinery.

During this saga, the council took three campaigners to court to prevent them taking “unlawful direct action or from encouraging others to take direct action”. After a judge ruled in favour of the council, it is now reportedly seeking costs from two of the campaigners of £27,000.

It’s not over yet

Meanwhile, emails revealed South Yorkshire Police “taking orders” directly from Amey over its operations. Recently, The Canary exposed how the council was running a surveillance operation against campaigners and residents; one which campaigners believe could be illegal. A petition has also been launched, calling on the Labour Party in Sheffield to ballot its members over the tree felling programme.

Lodge’s departure is interesting timing. Following a mild embarrassment in the local elections, has Lodge fallen on his sword, Amber Rudd-style, for the greater good of Labour-led Sheffield City Council? If so, it’s unlikely to wash with many campaigners, who believe the only solution to the tree felling saga is root and branch reform within Sheffield Labour Party.

Get Involved!

– Read more of The Canary‘s coverage on the Sheffield trees saga.

– Sign No Stump City’s petition.

Featured image via Jepps Books – Twitter

We need your help ...

The coronavirus pandemic is changing our world, fast. And we will do all we can to keep bringing you news and analysis throughout. But we are worried about maintaining enough income to pay our staff and minimal overheads.

Now, more than ever, we need a vibrant, independent media that holds the government to account and calls it out when it puts vested economic interests above human lives. We need a media that shows solidarity with the people most affected by the crisis – and one that can help to build a world based on collaboration and compassion.

We have been fighting against an establishment that is trying to shut us down. And like most independent media, we don’t have the deep pockets of investors to call on to bail us out.

Can you help by chipping in a few pounds each month?

The Canary Support us

Comments are closed