Independent Media | Campaigning Journalism
As the Tories failed yet again to show on Channel 4, Cathy Newman spoke on their behalf
On 8 December, Cathy Newman hosted Channel 4’s Britain Decides: Everything But Brexit Debate. Representatives from five of the UK’s main political parties debated the 2019 election issues apart from Brexit. And as it has done throughout this election campaign, the Conservative Party continued its tradition of not showing up.
But its non-appearance didn’t seem to matter that much, as Newman interjected at several points throughout the debate to answer on its behalf. And judging by the public’s reaction, people are utterly sick of this disrespectful and shameful Tory attitude.
It would hardly go unnoticed
This point wasn’t lost on the panel that did show up. Labour’s shadow education secretary Angela Rayner called it out:
“The Tories have failed & what’s really frustrating is they’re not here tonight & every now & again, you have to pitch in & say ‘this what the Conservatives have done’. Why are they not here to talk about their record?” Spot on @AngelaRayner #C4Debate
pic.twitter.com/fKt7lrKDpk— Ben #VoteLabour (@BenJolly9) December 8, 2019
Read on...
It’s a no show from the Tories
It goes without saying that political parties must face the electorate they want to lead. This way the public gets to cross examine their policies. So it’s really sad for democracy that the governing party has balked on so many occasions during this campaign.
The Conservative Party wasn’t there to answer for its appalling record on the NHS, climate change, or child poverty. But in any case, Newman saved it the trip. People watching clearly noticed this and they weren’t in the least bit happy:
As Tories have refused to go on #C4Debate tonight I don't see why Cathy Newman has to say what they might have said on their behalf. They had their chance and ducked it. As I typed that Angela Rayner made the same point to applause. Newman didn't like that though.
— Briefcase Michael (@BriefcaseMike) December 8, 2019
Why the hell is Cathy Newman speaking for the Tories?!
The Tories declined to take part, thats THEIR call. It should not he up to anyone else to defend their position if they cant be arsed even turning up tonight!
Come on @Channel4News, stop acting like Tory PR! #C4debate
— Stevie #ABZ 🏴🎥📱📺 (Media Guy) (@StevieCABZ) December 8, 2019
Although one person believed the Tories actually were there, but had merely taken a different form:
It is claimed that the Tories didn't turn up for this debate tonight ?
au contraire !
Jo Swinson and Cathy Newman were both representing the Conservative party; which seems a little unfair.. https://t.co/ftbufw6uVc
— Bob (Boswell) 🏴 🌎🇧🇷 (@Bob55492332) December 8, 2019
Johnson’s “cock up”
And surprisingly, it was perhaps Boris Johnson who gave the best explanation for his party’s absence. Perhaps he feels his party is guilty of one too many a “cock up” which no amount of “sensible” debating could ever hope to compensate for:
Boris Johnson claims that debates are essential, but neither he nor the Tories could be bothered to turn up tonight. They're afraid to defend their record. They are not on your side. #C4Debate pic.twitter.com/3tPA5skWwP
— The Labour Party (@UKLabour) December 8, 2019
If you can’t take it…
The Conservative Party’s attitude towards the debates and interviews in this election is an insult to the British people. It quite simply doesn’t want to answer to the public for its appalling record in government. It’s unprepared to appear unless it can manufacture some kind of cheap publicity stunt.
But it’s voters who have the final say, and they can make a shameful and unresponsive government pay this coming Thursday. More importantly, they can replace it with one that actually does care.
Featured image via Twitter – Channel 4
Do your bit for independent journalism
Did you know that less than 1.5% of our readers contribute financially to The Canary? Imagine what we could do if just a few more people joined our movement to achieve a shared vision of a free and fair society where we nurture people and planet.
We need you to help out, if you can.
When you give a monthly amount to fund our work, you are supporting truly independent journalism. We hold power to account and have weathered many attempts to shut us down and silence the counterpoint to the mainstream.
You can count on us for rigorous journalism and fearless opposition to an increasingly fascist government and right wing mainstream media.
In return you get:
- Advert free reading experience
- Behind the scenes monthly e-newsletter
- 20% discount from our shop
Fund us -
Show Comments
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to leave a comment.Join the conversationPlease read our comment moderation policy here.
Having the chairwoman of a debate speak up for the Tories in their absence is just an outrage. Just as in the past they spoke of the “political machine” like in Nazi Germany or Soviet Russia, this coming together of the Tory Party, the media, finance and the means of production is a neo-liberal machine. It’s a sinister development in neo-liberalism as it nears its end but clings desperately to survival.
Even Tory voters must have blushed and thought what are we coming to. I still think they intend to steal the election from Corbyn–hence the lies about leading the polls–but I think the numbers who may turn out for him may make it too big to rig, though in the Brexit north they may be able to pare his numbers.